judgement day: wile coyote

[spacetrace]

the jury voted :

2 votes innocent
2 votes guilty
1 abstention from voting

here the anonymus reasonings:
______________________________
1. The passwords are identical, the odds of this are very slim, and i know from persoanl experience that i keep most of my passwords the same for my email ect ect.

2. The Email adress of Both Coyote and Problem of *** are similar and both have the domain of @home.nl

3.The battlereports of Wile. Coyote show in one such case a fight against 7 motherships. And this has happened more than once. I doubt very much that a newbie would use the same fleet setup again if he saw that he lost points..

comment:
i did not found any significant number of suspicious battle reports
______________________________

The fact that wile has the same password as problem of ***
The fact that wile's real name is the same as wagges of van dalen
this second argument is not really strong, but well this new information for me, including all i send before say enough for me.

comment:
if you register an account for your friend you may use an own second email

______________________________

i think he is innocent, some of his brs are suspicious but i meet them also sometimes.

______________________________

I think Wile is innocent, i couldn't find enough evidences. I looked through everything but nothing convinces me that he is multi-ing. Also talking to some people got me to no evidence at all.

Conviction: Not guilty... (*hammer*)

______________________________

so the jury voted 2 guilty ; 2 innocent:

this is the final decision:

wile coyote is guilty for minor cheating: SHARING ACCOUNTS which is a rule break too.

this speaks for wile coyote:
several trusted player wrote letters of recommendation, which tell that he is a good player .
he promised to keep the rules for the future.

this is the punishment:
- score penalty of 10000 points ( 5000 are already subtracted)
- social work: he got to teach several noobs how to play and how to keep the rules and why. for the future , if he gets asked in irc or by ingame mail.

the judge has spoken .